My original title for this article was “Sex, Drugs, and MLM Scams”, but I can never pass up alliteration.
[Today’s article is going to deal with adult themes. You might have already gathered that from the title.]
This past weekend a news story caught my eye. The Boston Globe reported on a lemonade delivery service. That’s not very exciting, but the lemonade comes with a free gift… a side of pot.
The price of this Tazo black tea lemonade is $55. And, of course, they only deliver the tea to people who are over 21.
It seems that in Massachusetts giving away pot is legal. A delivery service that sells lemonade is legal too. So the found of the company, HighSpeed, is a smart businessman, right?
According to the article the local authorities don’t view it that way. One chief legal counsel write, “Obviously this is a thinly concealed scheme to obscure the illegal sale of marijuana by an unlicensed seller.”
One part of the article that I want to focus is this:
“Without touching on specifics, [lawyer Adam] Fine offered one reasonable test for the legality of giving away a gift of marijuana with another product: Is the cost of the item being sold in line with its normal price, its fair market value?
The Tazo tea lemonade I paid for: $55.
Tazo tea lemonade online: $1.27 plus shipping.”
I love this test. Is the product being sold in line with its normal price… its fair market value”
I’m not law enforcement, but if I were I’d tell them that they have to change their pricing if they want to continue what they are doing.
Prostitution
Let’s move on to sex, shall we?
Years ago, when I was in college, I had a brainstorm of a condom store. This store would focus on providing extremely great customer service for its patrons. To make sure that the condoms are of the best quality, the store would offer males a free demonstration with a member of its female staff.
Of course, the condoms from this store would sell for hundreds of dollars.
As George Carlin once said, “[Sexual Intercourse] is legal. Selling is legal. Why isn’t selling [sexual Intercourse] legal?” Mr. Carlin used a little more colorful language.
Of course we can use Adam Fine’s test here. The fair market value of condoms is not hundreds of dollars. I wouldn’t expect this kind of condom store to stay in business for very long, even though, technically, it would seem to be legal.
Pyramid Schemes
Back in 2008, I wrote an article about MonaVie, which was marketing a $45 bottle of juice. That price is very close to HighSpeed’s $55 price for its lemonade, right? It didn’t even come with a special delivery service.
MonaVie became a billion dollar company. Who knew there was such a large market for $45 juice, right?
A couple of years ago MonaVie was foreclosed upon for only 15 million.
What happened? MonaVie was an MLM company. MLM companies pair their products with what is billed as a “business opportunity.” I put that in quotes, because MLM is not a business and well over 99% of people lose money at it.
In MonaVie’s case, the opportunity required being “qualified” which could be done by buying the juice or selling the juice to others. As the fair market value for juice is closer to the $1.27 lemonade than the $55 that HighSpeed charges, I suspect few people actually bought the juice in comparison to the number of people who bought it themselves to be qualified for the “opportunity.”
It’s really the same concept as the HighSpeed’s marijuana or my mythical condom store above. In MLM, the questionable activity, the recruited pyramid of a business “opportunity”, is legitimized by the selling of product that is often not in line with its fair market value. That’s why the FTC has guidelines on MLMs/pyramid schemes.
My advice to readers is run away from any MLM that doesn’t have its product priced at its fair market value. For example, DoTerra’s essential oils can cost 10 times more than other oils. My analysis of Le-Vel Thrive shows that the vitamins can be as much as 50 times (seriously!) the fair market value.
My challenge to these companies is simply to put the product in retail at its pricing without the “opportunity.” You’ll probably never see an MLM company do that because consumers simply won’t buy the products and they’ll be out of business.
Conclusion
I think some people wonder why I’m so against MLM.
Pot has been shown to fairly safe. Safe, consensual sex harms no one. Pyramid schemes cause great financial harm. Unfortunately, law enforcement isn’t given the tools to shut down pyramid schemes.
Maybe someday that will change.
Now I’m off to research some retail locations with a bunch of rooms with beds. There’s a local hotel that went out of business recently, which could be exactly what I’m looking for.
Another great post. I really enjoy your sense of humor.
LM —
Hilarious article! I love the spin you put on MLM products not being competitively priced, especially since it comes up frequently in debates with pro MLMers.
I can’t help but think about being propositioned for Amway through the WWDB (World Wide Dream Builders) line of sponsorship. Not only were the Amway products expensive in comparison to the market place, but so were the “tools” that WWDB provided to help “your business”. They “offered” cds instead of downloadable MP3’s for purchase and they “offered” you to purchase a voicemail program instead of utilizing your cell phone and e-mail. Not only were these ancient forms of what we use currently but they were MORE expensive as well. My cell phone does all of the same things “communiKate” does and more while costing me less per month! Also, I would still need a cell phone even if I had their “communiKate” program, but I don’t need their program if I have a cell phone.
Total absurdity!
$114 (as overhead) for all the tools you’ll need plus a monthly order of things you literally buy any way, in other stores (which all add up to a high number, but you’re clearly not budgeting your money) to build a legacy business, to provide for your family (or just yourself if you’re selfish) and get time back in your life to enjoy every moment?!? Yah total absurdity….. You clearly don’t understand the difference between building a business with WWDB and a Rick and mortar self owned business… not knocking those mom and pops or anything like that, but they could even tell you the crazy amount of overhead they have, whether they’re making money or not with their business… so if $114 a month is crazy to you, then you shouldn’t be aloud to have the opportunity to own your own business.
Robin,
I don’t know what you are talking about since you didn’t make it clear. It seems like you might be referring to an MLM scheme. If so, you should understand that MLM is not a business. If we were talking about a business that’s a different story.
Most of the Big Whales in MLM got there, not by selling or recruiting people to sell, but by selling to recruits, and by offering training materials and hosting “Power Weekend” seminars for their own people. Jam 2000 reps in a venue at $15 per head, that rents out for $2500 and you’ve won the lottery. Do this 6-8 times a year and you’re considered a legend.
@LazyMan Speaking of MonaVie, guess who’s back? Dallin Larsen, CEO of MonVie has just started a NEW MLM, this one is called “Vasayo”. They started this company with NO PRODUCT, just a name, and the MonVie crowd came flocking in. The product they’ve come out with is a line of Liposome wrapped supplements. Some in a spray gel form and some in pills. $50 for the “membership kit”, $50-70 dollars per bottle of…uh…stuff. Must purchase $160 a month to stay “qualified”. They are also offering “Founders Packs” for $1500 dollars that allows the buyer to enter into a pool of 7000 people who will share a 2% lifetime stake in the company. As long as they are buying their $160 a month and have the right amount downline, that is. The comp plan is yet another variation on the “weak leg/strong leg” setup. All the upline are former MonaVie people. You might want to look at this one before it gets enormous and sucks in a bunch more suckers. Someone bought my way into this against my will so I have access to the back office if you want any information. https://www.vasayo.com/
Thanks for the comments people. I was a little nervous about writing on the topic as I like to keep the blog a family-friendly place.
Vasayo looks like a piece of garbage to me. However, BehindMLM gives it a pretty decent review (in comparison to some MLMs): http://behindmlm.com/mlm-reviews/vasayo-review-solid-retail-offering-from-the-founder-of-monavie/. That’s usually a trusted source. I haven’t looked to see if they comply with the FTC’s recent guidance here: https://www.ftc.gov/system/files/documents/public_statements/993473/ramirez_-_dsa_speech_10-25-16.pdf. Thus far I haven’t found any MLMs that have chosen to.